By Ira Madison

Once again, Idol turns out another legitimate music competition season. It’s not like I’m watching a teen pop show anymore, it’s like I’m watching legitimately talented people compete against one another. Nevermind the fact that no one this season was born before 1984… the music was surprisingly eclectic for a “Year You Were Born” theme. That probably had something to do with a lot of the songs not even being from the damn year these kids were born in. And of course, we’re still in the phase of the competition where some people are crumbling under the pressure too, so on with it:
NAIMA ADEDAPO
Tina Turner, “What’s Love Got to Do With It” (1984)
Whenever Naima’s assigned producer says they wanna make her “current,” like with last week’s “Umbrella” disaster, I think what they really mean is “embarrassing.” Because this up-tempo, pop-ified version of Tina’s hit was a hot damn mess. She was bouncing all over the stage like a drunk hopeful at a Girlicious reunion and I honestly have no idea what kind of career she wants to have. But I’d like her to stop experimenting on my television screen.
Grade: C+
PAUL MCDONALD
Elton John, “I Guess That’s Why They Call It the Blues” (1983)
How odd that this song came out in 1983, because Paul was born in 1984. This won’t be the first of Idol’s shennanigans as far as year discrepancies are concerned. The argument that it was released in the UK first doesn’t even fly either, since it hit the US charts six months later. At any rate, this song was the usual Paul fare. He’s always good, if you’re a fan of his voice. I’m a huge fan of his, but for some reason, maybe it was him being sick, I wasn’t really into his rendition of an Elton John tonight. The falsetto came across folksy and light, which contrasts with how Elton delivers his songs in a mostly earnest way.
Grade: B
THIA MEGIA
Vanessa Williams, “Colors of the Wind” (1995)
It was at this point that I really got over Thia. First off, I hate it when high schoolers get on Idol and have an obsession with singing ballads. We get it. You have a good voice. Now do something else with it besides pander for votes from pageant enthusiasts. But aside from singing a ballad, this heffa picked a song from Pocahontas. I know Vanessa Williams got a Grammy nom out of it, BUT REALLY. She also had the gall to claim that she felt it was appropriate, with what’s going on in the world right now. Because people in Japan are fucking talking to animals and trees.
Grade: C+
JAMES DURBIN
Bon Jovi, “I’ll Be There For You” (1989)
James managed to stay in his comfort box of trying to single white female Adam Lambert by tackling hair metal this week. It was good, as it usually is with James. He has a great control of his voice and he really does sell rocker. But in the context of the show, he hasn’t stepped out of Lambert’s shadow yet and really made a song his own yet. This sounded somewhat like a really good karaoke song and less like he was murdering the stage.
Grade: B+
HALEY REINHART
Whitney Houston, “I’m Your Baby Tonight” (1990)
Maybe I was smoking crack last week when I thought Haley’s rendition of “Blue” was awesome. But my high definitely wore off by the time I heard her slaughter a Whitney song like Lizzie Bordern hacking away at her parents. She was warbling like a pre-sacrificial goat and was hardly on pitch and just made me pity the hell out of her, the judges and the audience.
Grade: D
STEFANO LANGONE
Simply Red, “If You Don’t Know Me By Now”
This is a cover of a 1972 song, but it was made popular by Simply Red so I’ll allow it. Stefano is a really, really good singer. At first, I was irritated with him for relying on typical pretty boy belting as so many early ousters on this show do. But I could actually see him singing some great R&B tunes like Bruno Mars or something. It’s a shame he’ll probably end up like Day26 reject Donnie Klang. He was really good though. I’m only knocking off points for acting like he was above singing “Hanging Tough” or “Funky Cold Medina” in his interview.
Grade: A-
PIA TOSCANO
Whitney Houston, “Where Do Broken Hearts Go” (1988)
Serviceable performance, but I’m still not a Pia convert. I was also distracted by her irritating interview about how she could only be calmed down as a kid by having herself videotaped singing. Yeah, it’s about as retarded as it sounds. She was also dressed like Jennifer Lopez auditioning for a remake of Dynasty in this all white pantsuit and I was terribly, terribly horrified just watching her in general. Oh, and the singing. Like I said, I guess it was good. But maybe I just need to start closing my eyes when she performs.
Grade: B
SCOTTY MCCREERY
Travis Tritt, “Can I Trust You With My Heart” (1992)
Scotty was born in 1993, a full year after this “song from the year he was born” came out. I started with that because I am really having a hard time judging Scotty songs. I like country songs, but he sings them in the most irritating deadpan voice that I guess is perfectly on pitch but it’s such a low, gravelly mind-numbing pitch that I can’t be bothered with it.
Grade: B-
KAREN RODRIGUEZ
Taylor Dane, “Love Will Lead You Back” (1990)
1) Stop it with the lies, Idol! Karen was born in 1989, this song came out in January 1990! 2) Karen is so unmemorable I thought her name was Carmen. The most interesting thing about her is that her sister likes Nick Jonas. Or maybe it was Joe. I don’t care. I don’t even remember how she sang this song. I just remember writing down bland.
Grade: C+
CASEY ABRAMS
Nirvana, “Smells Like Teen Spirit” (1991)
I didn’t ever expect to hear a Nirvana song on Idol, but I’m glad I did. Because God, was it fantastic. Is there any way Casey isn’t winning this show? He’s phenomenal. He knows it, the judges know it and the audience knows it. It was just an all-around fantastic performance from someone who knows exactly who they are as an artist. He can do funk, he can do rock, and when it’s all blended together it is a beautiful, beautiful thing. I also really liked Casey’s gruff and earnest performance, which is a nice contrast to Cobain’s laid back rendition.
Grade: A
LAUREN ALAINA
Melissa Etheridge, “I’m the Only One” (1993)
This song was technically still on the charts in 1994, when Lauren was born, but I won’t quibble because she was really quite good. Lauren tapped into the heartbreak of the song, which seems like a better arena for her than trying to be sexy like she did last week. Maybe she really is a Kelly Clarkson.
Grade: A-
JACOB LUSK
Heart, “Alone” (1987)
Was it as good as this? No, it was not.
Grade: B-
By the way, I forgot to weigh in last week with the abysmal Michael Jackson medley on elimination night and my correctly predicted ouster of Ashston. I’ll make sure to do that tomorrow.
Bottom Predictions: Naima, Karen, Haley
Loser Predictions: Naima “Back to Cleaning Up at Summerfest” Adedapo